I tried on work tops at Gap, Banana Republic, and Old Navy. I learned higher prices don't always mean better quality.

July 1, 2025 adminsr

2025-07-01T14: 37: 01z

I tried on button-up tops at Gap, Banana Republic, and Old Navy.
The shirts from Gap and Banana Republic were the same price, but were made up of different fabrics.
In my opinion, the Old Navy option was comfortable, breathable, and versatile.

As someone who has worked remotely for the past five years, my collection of business-appropriate attire has dwindled from my closet.

I spend most days at my desk or in a coffee shop wearing athleisure, which leaves me stumped when it comes time to dress for in-person meetings or networking events.

I’m all for colorful style choices and elegant blouses, but a good button-up is the base of any corporate wardrobe. So, I went to my local Gap Inc.-owned stores — Gap, Banana Republic, and Old Navy — to search for a button-up that was flattering, high-quality, and comfortable. Here’s how it went.

My first stop of the day was at Gap.

Gap carries some good summer basics.

Chloe Caldwell

I’ve come to rely on Gap for everyday basics and trending pieces.

Since it’s officially summer, I reached for a linen button-up shirt that would keep me cool while looking put together.

I especially appreciated that this option was made of 100% linen, making the $80 price tag seem reasonable.

The top was comfortable, but a few details stood out.

Chloe wears a blue linen button-up shirt over a white top and a long white flowy skirt in a Gap fitting room. — I thought the collar on this shirt felt a bit flimsy.

Chloe Caldwell

Upon trying it on, I loved that the top felt comfortable and lightweight. I was also drawn to the slightly oversize fit and variety of color options, offering lots of summer styling possibilities.

However, I noticed that the collar felt a bit flimsy, and I would have liked more structure around the neckline. Also, the stitching on the buttons was white, which didn’t blend subtly with the light blue color of the top. Although it’s a small detail, this stood out to me.

Overall, though, I liked the fit and style of the Gap shirt. However, I wanted to compare it to the options available at the other Gap Inc. retailers.

Next, I visited Banana Republic, which is known for its elevated style and attainable luxury.

The inside of a Banana Republic store, with a table displaying clothes and two mannequins to the right of the table. — Banana Republic (location I visited not pictured) clothing isn’t always in my price range.

Sorbis/Shutterstock

Almost every time I’ve browsed at Banana Republic in the past year or so, I’ve been shocked at the high price of basic items.

I can’t always justify the cost of the brand’s clothing, but I do generally love the its elevated takes on everyday wear. So, I tried on another linen button-up top there.

This top was also $80 — but the fabric was a linen-blend.

Chloe wears a blue button-up shirt over a long white flowy skirt in a Banana Republic fitting room. — I thought the material felt itchy.

Chloe Caldwell

The Banana Republic shirt cost the same as the Gap option, but it was made of a linen-blend consisting of 55% linen and 45% rayon. That was an immediate turn-off for me, considering the price.

In terms of style and quality, the collar and overall material did feel more structured and like it would last through many wears and washes. However, the fabric wasn’t as breathable and felt itchy against my skin.

Based on my try-on experienceI wouldn’t buy this shirt, especially for the hot summer season.