20 things you may be recycling by mistake, and why you shouldn't be

Aerosol cans are metal with plastic caps, which should be recycled separately. Some recyclers accept the cans but others don’t.

You’ll want to make sure they’re empty if you can recycle them, especially if the cans contained chemicals.

“Some of these are dangerous to put in the blue bin,” Buch said.

Some cities, like Seattle and New York, have barred people from throwing batteries in the trash because they can cause chemical leaks and fires. Batteries usually can’t be recycled curbside, either.

Instead, a battery recycling facility needs to take them, Buch said.

If you want to recycle them, you can find retail locations willing to take batteries on the site Call2Recycle.

Chip bags, granola bar wrappers, and other snack packages are often multi-layered materials, Buch said.

“You’ve got foil on the outside,” he said. “You’ve got a plastic coating on the inside, and that’s not recyclable.”

The machines aren’t able to separate the layers, he said.

Some brands’ packaging is recyclable through How2Recycle, though you’ll have to drop it off at a participating grocery store or retailer.

There isn’t good technology to recycle ceramics, Buch said. They can even damage equipment.

The same is true for heat-resistant glass used to make items like baking dishes. Unwanted ceramics can usually be discarded in the household trash.

Over the years, coffee companies have made their pods more environmentally friendly by switching to a different type of recyclable plastic. But you still can’t just toss them in your recycling right out of the machine.

“The foil is recyclable,” Buch said. “The plastic is recyclable.” But you have to remove the foil top from the plastic cup. As with all other recycling, it should be clean and dry.

Even when properly separated, though, the pods can be what Buch calls a “nuisance item.” They’re so small that they often fall through slots or holes in sorting machines instead of getting recycled.

“Anything that’s 2 inches or smaller is going to fall out of the sorting system,” Buch said.

There are still ways to recycle some pods, though. Nescafé accepts pods you return to them, for example.

Disposable diapers are difficult to recycle “even if you didn’t have all the poop inside,” Buch said. They contain a variety of materials, like plastic and cellulose.

Some recycling companies like TerraCycle might take them, but municipal facilities most likely won’t.

Some companies abroad, like Germany’s BASF, are making advancements in chemically recycling diapers using the process of gasification, Plastics News reported.

Cellphones, printers, and computers contain plastic, metal, and a mix of other materials that make them poorly suited for standard recycling systems.

Many cities have separate facilities where you can drop off e-waste, or you might be able to schedule a special pickup. For example, if you have a coffee maker that’s gone kaput, a retailer like Staples might recycle it and other small appliances for free.

In 2018, the US generated 35.7 million tons of plastic waste and only recycled about 9% of it, according to the EPA’s most recent estimates. Because there are so many different kinds of plastics, it can be difficult to know what you can and cannot throw in your blue bin.

Many plastic containers have a little symbol: recycling arrows with a number in the center. This is what’s known as a resin identification code.

Most recycling facilities accept empty, clean, dry number 1 or 2 plastic. Some locations accept numbers 1 through 7, while others won’t take numbers 3, 6, or 7. It’s best to check before you chuck your plastic in the bin.

PVC, which is number 3, is used to make inflatable pool toys, faux leather, and other goods, and is very difficult to recycle.

There are many types of light bulbs, from CFLs to LEDs. It’s important to figure out what type you have before tossing it because many municipalities have different rules about where they go.

“Some of the old light bulbs even have mercury or other kinds of chemicals in them, like fluorescent light bulbs,” Buch said. So you may have to take them to your local hazardous waste collection site.

Some hardware stores will take certain types of bulbs, and Batteries Plus accepts a wide variety, including LEDs, incandescent bulbs, and fluorescent tubes.

Needles, syringes, and other sharp medical products can injure workers at waste and recycling facilities. Some locations have drop boxes or other collection sites that take them.

Safe Needle Disposal offers lists of disposal locations by state as well as mail-in services, which often require a fee.

You may know that you only used a paper towel to dry your hands, but the recycling facility doesn’t. They have to assume it could have been covered in food, grease, or even something hazardous.

“Those things become contaminated waste in the blue bin,” Buch said.

Plus, the fibers in these paper products are too short to get recycled.

Plastic utensils have a few traits that make them a no-go for the recycling bin. For starters, the size and shape of plastic utensils mean it’s hard for them to be processed by machinery. These objects often cause jams or other issues in machines.

Additionally, they’re often made from a mix of plastics that can be hard to separate.

The waste collection company Republic Services conducted a survey of over 2,000 Americans, which found that 38% of those surveyed recycled plastic cutlery, as reported by Recycling Today.

As with coffee pods, some prescription pill bottles and their lids are small enough to fall through sorting machines and won’t be recycled.

“There might be some communities where they don’t take the pill bottle and other communities where they do,” Buch said.

Cardboard is one of the most recycled materials in the US, but over half of what’s tossed still ends up in landfills, according to a 2019 estimate.

While most pizza boxes are made of cardboard, they’re also often greasy. “Sometimes the cardboard has cheese stuck to it, so now you’ve got cardboard with food, so it’s contaminated,” Buch said.

Some facilities will still take the boxes if they’re not too dirty.

While many people may throw their finished bottles in the recycling bin without much of a second thought, excess foods or liquids can complicate the recycling process. Briefly rinsing all residue from containers and letting them dry is the best practice.

If bottles still contain liquid, they could damage machinery or be rejected by the automated sorting process, according to Recycle Now.

Plastic bags and film and bubble wrap can cause serious problems for recycling equipment, acting a bit like hair caught around a vacuum roller brush.

“Plastic film stretches and becomes literally filament-like,” Buch said. “It gets wrapped around inside these sorting systems.”

The Republic Services survey found that 41% percent of those surveyed recycled plastic shopping bags.

Many grocery stores have collection boxes for plastic bags.

Whether you should leave plastic tops on water bottles before recycling them varies between municipalities.

“The lid is made of a different material than the plastic bottle itself,” Buch said, so they’re recycled differently.

Many facilities can separate the cap and bottle. However, you’ll still want to check with your local recycler because some require cap-free bottles.

Many cities and states have banned Styrofoam food containers, but the substance still arrives in a lot of products and shipping packaging.

Styrofoam, also known as polystyrene, isn’t recyclable in most curbside bins. Many cities have drop-off sites, though they may only take certain types, like Styrofoam blocks.

Though receipts can sometimes seem paper-like enough for the recycling bin, the thermal paper that most are printed on contains chemicals like Bisphenol-A and Bisphenol-S, which could contaminate other paper in the recycling stream or find their way into wastewater, per the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.

So the next time you’re cleaning out your coat pockets, those receipts that have been in there for a year can go straight to the trash.

Much like receipts, recycling photos and glossy paper may seem acceptable, but the coating on most photo paper contains metals or plastic.

If you’re unsure about whether certain other glossy materials, like wrapping paper, can be recycled, you can perform the “rip test” as outlined by Ecology Center. If the material doesn’t rip in the manner printer paper would, it’s most certainly not recyclable.